Introduction
Let’s be honest. You didn’t start your business because you love spreadsheets. You started it to follow a passion, sell a product, or provide a service.
But as your business grows, the financial side becomes a monster.
Receipts pile up. Tax deadlines loom. Cash flow gets tricky.
Suddenly, you realise: “I need help.”
Choosing an accounting firm is one of the most critical decisions a small business owner makes. A good accountant saves you money, time, and stress. A bad one can lead to audits, penalties, and sleepless nights.
In 2024, the landscape has changed. You aren’t limited to the CPA down the street. You have access to powerful online firms, hybrid services, and specialised experts.
In this comprehensive guide, we will review the Best Accounting Firms for Small Business, explain the difference between online and traditional CPAs, and help you find the perfect match for your wallet.
Part 1: Do You Need a Local CPA or an Online Firm?
This is the first question you must answer.
1. The Local CPA (Traditional)
This is the accountant with an office in your city. You can drive there, shake hands, and drink coffee with them.
- Pros: Personalised relationship. They know local tax laws intimately. Good for complex situations (like owning multiple properties or facing an audit).
- Cons: Often more expensive. Slower response times (they might not reply to emails instantly).
- Best For: Manufacturing, Construction, Restaurants with heavy cash flow.
2. The Online Accounting Firm (Modern)
These are tech-first companies. They pair you with a dedicated bookkeeper/CPA, but everything happens via an app or web portal.
- Pros: Real-time dashboards. Faster communication. Often cheaper due to efficiency. Integrates perfectly with tools like Stripe, Shopify, and Gusto.
- Cons: Less “face-to-face” connection.
- Best For: E-commerce, Agencies, Tech Startups, Freelancers.
Part 2: The Top 5 Accounting Firms for Small Business (2024 Review)
I have analysed the market based on pricing, technology, and customer support. Here are the winners.
1. Bench (Best for Online Bookkeeping)
Bench is the industry leader for a reason. They give you a dedicated bookkeeping team and intuitive software.
- How it works: You connect your bank accounts. They import transactions and categorise them for you. At the end of the month, you get a beautiful financial statement.
- Pros: Extremely user-friendly. Great catch-up services if you are behind on books.
- Cons: They handle bookkeeping, not tax filing (though they have a “Bench Tax” add-on partner).
- Pricing: Starts around $299/month.
2. Pilot (Best for Startups & Tech)
If you run a startup funded by investors (VCs), Pilot is your best bet. They specialise in high-growth companies.
- How it works: They use a mix of software and expert CPAs. They understand complex things like “Burn Rate” and “R&D Tax Credits.”
- Pros: Integrates with tech stacks (Stripe, Brex, Gusto). CFO services available.
- Cons: Expensive for simple businesses.
- Pricing: Starts around $599/month.
3. 1-800Accountant (Best Full-Service for Small Biz)
This is a nationwide firm that combines the power of a large team with dedicated support.
- How it works: They assign you a dedicated accountant who learns your business. They handle everything—bookkeeping, payroll, and taxes.
- Pros: Comprehensive service. They help with entity formation (LLC set up), too. Good for traditional businesses.
- Cons: Some users report varying response times depending on the assigned accountant.
- Pricing: Custom quotes (usually flat monthly fees).
4. Bookkeeper360 (Best for Xero/QuickBooks Users)
If you already use Xero or QuickBooks Online and just want someone to manage it, this is the one.
- How it works: They are experts in these platforms. They offer “Pay-as-you-go” options, which is rare.
- Pros: Very flexible. Great reporting dashboard. HR and Payroll solutions included.
- Cons: Requires you to be on specific software ecosystems.
- Pricing: Starts around $399/month.
5. Local CPA (YourNeighbourhood Expert)
Never underestimate the power of a local expert.
- How to find one: Don’t just use Google. Ask for referrals from other business owners. Look for CPAs who specialise in your industry.
- Why choose them: If you are being audited by the IRS, you want someone who can physically show up and represent you.
Part 3: What Services Should You Actually Pay For?
Accounting firms try to upsell. Do you need the “Platinum Package”? Probably not.
Here is the hierarchy of needs:
- Bookkeeping (Essential): Categorising income and expenses. You need this monthly to know if you are profitable.
- Tax Preparation (Essential): Filing your annual returns. Do not DIY this unless you are a freelancer with zero expenses.
- Payroll (Essential if you have staff): Paying employees and handling payroll taxes. This is legally risky to mess up; outsource it immediately.
- CFO Services (Optional): Strategic advice (“Should I hire more people?”, “Can I afford a new office?”). Only pay for this when you are making significant revenue ($500k+).
Part 4: How Much Should You Budget?
Cost is the biggest friction point. Here is a realistic breakdown for 2024:
- Micro-Business (Revenue < $50k): Use software like FreshBooks or Wave ($15-$30/month) + a CPA for annual taxes ($500 one-time).
- Small Business (Revenue $100k – $500k): Online firms like Bench ($300/month) or a local bookkeeper.
- Growing Business (Revenue $1M+): Full-service firm or in-house accountant ($2,000+ per month).
Tip: Don’t look at accounting as a “Cost.” Look at it as “Profit Protection.” A good accountant will find deductions that pay for their own fee.
Part 5: Red Flags (When to Fire Your Accountant)
If you already have one, how do you know if they are bad?
Watch out for these signs:
- Reactive, not Proactive: They only talk to you when you call them. A good accountant should call you before tax season to save you money.
- Jargon-Heavy: They use complex words to confuse you. A good accountant explains things simply.
- Missed Deadlines: This is unforgivable. If they file late and you get fined, fire them immediately.
Conclusion: Making the Choice
In 2024, you don’t have to struggle with spreadsheets alone.
Whether you choose the sleek efficiency of Bench, the specialised expertise of Pilot, or the trusted handshake of a Local CPA, the goal is the same: Clarity.
You need to know your numbers to grow your numbers.
Take a step today. Schedule a free consultation with one of these firms. It might be the most profitable meeting you have all year.
FAQ: Common Questions
Q1: Can I just use QuickBooks/Xero myself?
A: Yes, if you have accounting knowledge. But remember: Software is just a tool. It doesn’t know tax laws. Garbage in, garbage out. If you categorise things incorrectly, your tax return will be wrong.
Q2: Is it safe to share bank details online?
A: Yes. Firms like Bench and Pilot use “Read-Only” access. They can see your transactions to categorise them, but they cannot move your money. It uses bank-level encryption.
Q3: When should I hire an accountant?
A: The moment you separate your business and personal finances. If you have a business bank account, you should have a professional look at it.
Q4: Is the fee tax-deductible?
A: Yes! Accounting and legal fees are 100% tax-deductible business expenses
Links:-
Disclaimer: I am not a CPA. This article is for informational purposes only. Please consult a professional for tax advice.”